Belief and the function of doctrine dr michael s burdett university of oxford. Review of lindbecks the nature of doctrine framepoythress. Religion and theology in a postliberal age underlining by lindbeck isbn. A medievalist and historical theologian, lindbeck taught at yale divinity school from 1952 to 1993. Postliberal theology has, by and large, taken the form of an extensive research project initiated by george lindbeck s the nature of doctrine in 1984 and so, as a theological project, it tends to be a bit formalistic. Religion and theology in a postliberal age, published in 1984. Uploaded by booksalecataloger1 on september 27, 2011. Underlying lindbecks fascination with doctrine, there is the more fundamental matter of thought and language as models of reality. In addition to his account of the nature of religion, lindbeck also addresses. Lindbeck s postliberal theology is both a theory of religion and a regulative theory of doctrine. However, for most of his career he was known primarily as a medievalist and, above all, as a theologian at the forefront of ecumenical dialogue. The foundations of christian doctrine pdf epub download. May 25, 2012 lindbeck believes he can resolve this apparent contradiction by a particular theory of the nature of doctrine.
While lindbecks bestknown work is the nature of doctrine, there is one mustread article for evangelicals which expresses what he believes the reading of scripture should look like. A true classic, this book sets forth the central tenets of a postliberal approach to theology, emphasizing a culturallinguistic approach to religion and a rule theory of doctrine. Third, his quest for the nature of doctrine is a bold and challenging one in that he attempts to modify the introduction of systematic theology in order to. His postliberal theology proposes a culturallinguistic theory of religion in contrast to the cognitivepropositional and experientialexpressive theories of religion. Lindbeck and the identity of the christian tradition 176 3. Lindbeck s theory, and some conservative proposals, harbour ideological intrusions alien to the christian confession, thereby illustrating that critique is needed precisely because of, and for the sake of, that confession. Lindbeck fails to sufficiently support christian belief, or reason itself. This formalism, moulaison argues, is not just an acceptable byproduct of academic work but is a specifically theological problem. His short book the nature of doctrine has received wide attention, and been widely criticised. In the nature of doctrine, lindbeck uses the word truth in three different senses. Read download the foundations of christian doctrine pdf. Lindbeck believes he can resolve this apparent contradiction by a particular theory of the nature of doctrine.
In his the nature of doctrine 1984, george lindbeck offered a culturetheoretical approach to doctrine over against liberal and conservative approaches. Alasdair macintyre, george lindbeck and the nature of. Lindbeck contended that religious traditions are historically shaped and culturally encoded, wrote gary dorrien in a 2001 century article about postliberalism. Professor geoffrey wainwright, the divinity school, duke university, durham, north carolina 27706, usa. Then, in my last semester, i was assigned the nature of doctrine. A reflection george lindbeck has written an important and what promises to be an influential book.
Mcgrath begins his book by critically engaging the views of george lindbeck on doctrine before moving on to present a fresh understanding of the nature and function of christian doctrine within the church. It is now thirty years since george lindbeck provided, in the nature of doctrine, an epitome of his approach to ecumenical dialogue, and an affirmation of related ways of studying religion and. There his original and suggestive ruletheory reading of doctrine is developed. Mcgrath on lindbeck doctrine is primarily a social phenomenon. Yet george lindbeck s the nature of doctrine accomplished such a feat in less than 150 pages. George lindbeck saved my christianity the christian century. In short, the culturallinguistic approach parallels talking about god and learning a language. Very few theologians spark a generations of scholarship, much less just one work of those theologians. This chapter analyzes the second stage of postliberal theology, which is dominated by lindbecks the nature of doctrine and freis essays from the 1980s. Alasdair macintyre, george lindbeck and the nature of tradition. For lindbeck, different religions and cultures happen in different times and places, but each sharing some common practical elements such as treating your neighbors rightly.
In this essay i analyse and criticize george lindbeck s treatment of truth and meaning in his book the nature of doctrine. In a landmark 1984 work, the nature of doctrine, george lindbeck described two typical approaches to doctrine. Read ecumenical dimensions of lindbecks nature of doctrine, modern theology on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Pdf the nature of doctrine by george lindbeck matthew bryant.
While lindbeck s bestknown work is the nature of doctrine, there is one mustread article for evangelicals which expresses what he believes the reading of scripture should look like. After an explication of his general project in this work, i turn specifically to his discussion of truth and of its interaction with his understanding of meaning. Lindbeck proposes a withdrawal of the church into a ghetto. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Before discussing the nature of lindbecks postliberal program or its application to certain issues, we need to examine his understanding of truth, which is central to his larger project. Religion and theology in a postliberal age anniversary by lindbeck, george a. As the subtitled indicates, it was his desire to provide a framework for discussion. Religion and theology in a postliberal age helped launch the postliberal movement in theology. Critics have had three reservations in particular, marshall tells us. Pdf the nature of doctrine 25th anniversary edition. Jul 20, 2009 the nature of doctrine, originally published in 1984, is one of the most influential works of academic theology in the past fifty years. Use the link below to share a fulltext version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Lindbeck, 16 doctrines are primarily cognitive, intellectual statements of fact the doctrines speak truthfully about an objective reality and convey this truth.
Religion and theology in a postliberal age an understanding of doctrine that will aid ecumenical discussion, lindbeck sketches in this. This thesis is developed through a critique of george lindbeck s the nature of doctrine. Religion and theology in a postliberal age an understanding of doctrine that will aid ecumenical discussion, lindbeck sketches in. Lindbeck argues instead for a culturallinguistic approach, using language and. Truth and meaning in george lindbecks the nature of doctrine. Religion and theology in a postliberal age philadelphia. Lindbecks programmatic study the nature of doctrine. Theology in a postliberal age best expresses barths confessionalism.
In 1994, lindbeck spoke at length about his memories of vatican ii with george weigel, and a transcript of his interview with weigel was published in the december 1994 edition of first things. Doctrines are informative propositions or truth claims about objective realities. I am currently reading george lindbeck, the nature of doctrine, in its 2009 25th anniversary edition. Nature of doctrine by george a lindbeck has revolutionised theological thinking in the context of postmodern sensibilities. Review of george a lindbeck, the nature of doctrine. This groundbreaking work lays the foundation for a theology based on a culturallinguistic approach to religion and a regulative or rule theory of doctrine. A true classic, this book sets forth the central tenets of a post liberal approach to theology, emphasizing a culturallinguistic approach to religion and a rule theory of doctrine. The nature of doctrine by george lindbeck does not distinguish between objectives of different religious doctrines from their practices. It is a very important book and is one of the seminal works of the yale school of theology. In the intervening period, however, lindbeck s position has had to sustain criticism, at times to the point of denigration, as some have pointed out that lindbeck s analysis of the relation between. Summary in the nature of doctrine, lindbeck provides a framework for conceiving religion and religious doctrine in postliberal terms 7.
It has been the approach taken by most in the history of theology, and still taken by most evangelical theologians today. Respondents to lindbeck objected that he had misunderstood his opponents, but they displayed their own misunderstandings of his argument. Lindbeck is the author of the nature of doctrine 4. Lindbeck, 9780664246181, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
Pdf the nature of doctrine by george lindbeck matthew. Religious experience in the current theological discussion. It has rekindled the earlier rivalry between barthian confessionalism and schleiermachers liberalism. I seek a more fruitful engagement with lindbeck s work, proceeding by way of constructed. The nature of doctrine is, as lindbeck confessed, an introduction to what he calls postliberal theology. Belief and the function of doctrine emmaus psykologiforening.
The nature of doctrine, originally published in 1984, is one of the most influential works of academic theology in the past fifty years. Religion and theology in a postliberal age, established a theology that rejected modern liberal protestant thinking that defined. This article argues that the power of religion to shape experience presupposes the mobilization of religious identity through social opposition. The nature of doctrine chicago journals university of chicago. Instead, the nature of doctrine or religious claims should be culturallinguistic. Truth in wittgenstein, truth in lindbeck 9 keeper and a customer, the word five takes on meaning only because people engage in the practice of counting things.
Lindbeck is pitkin professor emeritus of historical theology in the department of religious studies and the divinity school, yale university. In the past, he says, doctrine has been understood as propositional truth orthodoxy or as the articulation of religious experience liberalism. Lindbeck the nature of doctrine pdf the nature of doctrine. A quarter century has now passed since george lindbeck first published the nature of doctrine. Language is a system of symbols which we use to do different jobs in our common life. He contends that the cultural linguistic view of religion, long current in the social sciences, can provide theology. Lindbeck 1923 is an american lutheran theologian who was involved in ecumenical dialogue. He contends that the culturallinguistic view of religion, long current in the social sciences, can provide theology. Truth and meaning in george lindbecks the nature of.
Pdf on oct 4, 2019, s david muthukumar and others published george a lindbeck, nature of doctrine. Although shaped intimately by theological concerns, this approach is consonant with the most advanced anthropological, sociological, and philosophical thought of our times. Lindbeck presented a new approach to viewing religion and doctrine in his book the nature of doctrine. In addition to his account of the nature of religion, george lindbeck also addresses the relationship between christianity and other religions, the resolution of. A major concern for lindbeck is to provide a framework for understanding the interrelationship of doctrinal permanence and change, conflict and compatibility. Hans zorn notes that the wittgensteinian example sen tence, this room has length has meaning simply because people measure things. Unfortunately, lindbeck never got around to publish a fuller treatment on his methodology, but some of his students have made great strides on his behalf.
The book explained to me why god felt close when i slept on noahs ark sheets, but utterly vague when i tried to be religious without the story i was raised on. Religion and theology in a postliberal age louisville. Mcgrath on the nature of doctrine issues with lindbecks four views p. Truth and meaning in george lindbeck s the nature of doctrine introduction in this essay i analyse and criticize george lindbeck s treatment of truth and meaning in his book the nature of doctrine.
Lindbeck contrasts his theories of religion and doctrine with cognitivepropositionalist theories and experientialexpressivist theories. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. First, lindbeck s main purpose in the nature of doctrine is to make sense of. One study as the title indicates is on the nature of doctrine. It does not stand on its own in the fabric of christian doctrine and is knit into the doctrines of the trinity. Lindbeck draws influence from wittgenstein philosopher of language, j. This is the understanding that doctrines make truth claims about objective. Lindbeck categorizes doctrine as one of the following three. All faiths have the same core experience, they just express it differently. The nature of doctrine, religion and theology in a post. Jan 23, 2018 lindbecks influential 1984 book, the nature of doctrine.
907 787 288 753 1396 346 145 474 1207 1285 432 1313 1653 602 412 916 477 371 909 952 651 1332 814 101 1253 1102 904 298 877